A Tale of Premiere, Avid and DaVinci Resolve

How do you edit a programme that was started in Adobe Premiere Pro, but that must be finished in Avid Media Composer?
Easy, you say, just export an AAF from Premiere and import it into Avid, but that causes all sorts of issues, so here I lay out how we solved this for a recent BBC 4 documentary.

Some background first – the programme was to be filmed in the Middle East but then, for various reasons, the Director would be unavailable for a month or so afterwards. During this time, he wanted to start assembling parts of the film himself, using Premiere Pro. The BBC mandated that the film be edited in Avid Media Composer, for compatibility with their on-line and sound workflows.

An AAF import of a sequence into Media Composer produces a bin full of all of the clips used in the timeline. In order to continue editing, it is more convenient if the timeline refers instead to existing clips in sorted bins in the project. For instance, performing a Match Frame in Media Composer should match to the sorted bins – where other, related footage resides, not to the clips created by the AAF import.

Riding to the rescue – as is so often the case – came DaVinci Resolve. This is the workflow we developed:

1) The picture and sound rushes were synchronised in Resolve. The Director and his crew were on the ball, with correct timecode on most of the clips, and a belt-and-braces clap on every clip too. Hurrah!
2) Resolve was used to output Quicktime wrapped DNxHR files. Quicktime (rather than Avid friendly MXF) was used as Premiere Pro is unable to parse the link between MXF files, and so treats the audio and video separately. As these Quicktimes would be used for online finishing, they were produced at camera resolution, with minimum compression and maximum colour fidelity.
3) Bins were created in the Premiere Pro project with clips for the exported Quicktimes.
4) Identical bins were also populated in Media Composer with AMA links to the same Quicktime files.
5) Premiere Pro was used to produce proxy files from the high-quality Quicktimes, to facilitate the use of the Director's poor old laptop. Premiere can automatically switch the timeline from proxies to full quality, and the bins are only populated with a single clip reference, so this process is more-or-less invisible to the Director.
6) Once the Director had finished his assembly, we crossed our fingers and hoped that Premiere Pro would produce a more-or-less workable AAF. Premiere chokes if you use any transitions, effects, resizing or repositioning and so on. Furthermore, it was important not to rename any clips, or transcode anything.
7) The AAF was imported into Media Composer, where it was relinked to the AMA clips by opening all the bins, selecting all the clips in each bin, and then relinking using the following settings in the Relink… dialog box:

Pasted Graphic

8) Offline media can then be created in Media Composer.

This process worked flawlessly. It was as if the edit had been started in Media Composer, with the Director's assembly transferred perfectly, frame-for-frame – though I won't say how much we kept.



Film and television are, perhaps, two of the few places where C.P. Snow’s ‘Two Cultures’ actually do communicate. An extraordinary amount of science and technology is required to produce these defining art forms of the 20th Century.
Imaging sensors use a variation of the photoelectric effect he described and here, too, there are developing two cultures – those who follow the Charge Coupled Device (or CCD) and those true believers in CMOS.

When is HD not HD (and 4k not 4k)?

In 1861, the Scottish physicist James Clerk Maxwell demonstrated the first colour photograph to the Royal Institution.
A 1080 sensor needs to generate 2073600 red, green and blue pixels in the output image (1920 x 1080). However, a 1080 Bayer sensor has only 1036800 green photosites and 518400 red and blue photosites, i.e. half the required number of green and only a quarter the number of red and blue.

FCP to Avid Workflows

I am often asked to edit TV programmes in Final Cut that will be finished in, or at least will somehow pass through an Avid system. This workflow is actually very straightforward, but can go horribly wrong if you don’t understand the different ways that Avid and Final Cut/Quicktime handle video. There is a lot of great information out there on the web, but also a lot of disinformation – with Avid fans dissing FCP and vice versa – so as a user of both, I thought I would try to draw it all together into one blog entry. Read More...

Less Technology - more Technique

There is a lot written about how to use editing software, but not much about how to edit – why some cuts work and others don’t, the techniques of montage, continuity and so on. Here, I try to redress the balance a little.

Imagine you saw the world like a film. You watch yourself from afar as you stroll to the pub. In the blink of an eye you are inside the pub - close up - watching yourself enter and scan the room for your friends. Read More...

Getting past the Geeks

Editing a TV programme is one thing, but there are a host of hoops to jump through before your masterpiece will be allowed on the telly. Here is a basic guide to passing tech review.

Amazingly, life as a professional editor is not all red carpets and lunch with Charlize Theron. Sometimes we have to do some work and show that, not only are we gifted and beautiful, but that we also know stuff.

Stitched up by interlace

Interlaced TV shouldn’t exist in the modern world, but somehow it hangs on in there. A quick overview of its history.

If you ever find yourself in Stirling, go and see the National Wallace Monument – a bizarre Victorian Gothic monster with an even more bizarre late 20th century statue of Mel Gibson in the car park. Read More...